Hi friends!
You know that when I make a new discovery in the beauty world, I gotta share it with you all. Last month I talked about a stand-out drugstore brow gel from Ardell in this post (which I’m still loving, by the way), and now I’m here with an amazing drugstore eyeliner recommendation!
OK, listen up. If you want a creamy, yet long-lasting drugstore eyeliner check out the L’Oreal Infallible Pro–Last Waterproof Eyeliner Pencils. They are sooo nice! I’ve long been an uber fan of the Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Gel Eyeliners, and I still am (you can shop the range when you visit my Shop tab). But this formula from L’Oreal is just as good in my opinion. I absolutely love it when I find something at the drugstore that’s cheaper but just as effective as a higher-end favorite!
Shop the L’Oreal Infallible Waterproof Eyeliner Pencils here. They’re less than $10 each; such a steal!
THE TEXTURE
This is a standard pencil liner format that needs sharpening as the product wears down. The first thing I noticed when I used this formula was the creaminess. Wow, is this baby smooth when you swipe it across your lash line!
It’s been a while since an eyeliner has impressed me, and this one truly has. I’ve tried so many pencil formulas from different brands over the years, and a lot of them tug and buckle on the skin which I absolutely hate. There’s no tugging here. It definitely has that waxy, long-wear texture that a lot of other pencils have, but this one gives you such smooth color and application. Major score!
You do get a few moments of playtime after you apply this product to smudge if you so choose. But then it sets for long–wear and doesn’t budge. I’ve typically worn this product for about 8 to 10 hours with no smudging or transferring. (Just so you’re aware, I do not have oily eyelids normally.)
THE COLORS
They have a very impressive range of colors in this line, ranging from bright purple, to teal, to grey and bronze. There are 15 shades in total from what I can see on L’Oreal’s website, although I’m not sure that all colors are carried in stores. For example, Ulta sells about 12 of the shades but a few are “online only.”
I first bought the shade Ivy, a beautiful shimmery olive green. After I fell in love with that one, I bought 4 more shades in Black (matte), Bronze (shimmery brown), Purple (iridescent violet), and Aubergine (slightly iridescent eggplant). I just had a little eyeliner declutter, so it was perfect timing to add a few more in my collection.
I’d say all of the colors perform very well. Although saying that, Purple has the tendency to almost blend away completely if you smudge it too much. And I do think it could be a bit brighter.
From left to right: Black, Aubergine, Bronze, Ivy, Purple.
ONE WARNING
I tried experimenting with these textures as cream shadows by putting them all over the lid, but don’t bother doing that. Due to their long-wear formula, these pencils are just too waxy to perform well in that capacity and they don’t blend out well over larger spaces on the eyes. I ended up hating my makeup that day since it looked so choppy, so take it from me and just use them for their intended purpose as eyeliners!
Have you guys used these eyeliners before? If so, what did you think? I’d love to know!
xo, Erica
PIN IT!
I was just in the makeup section the other day, looking at these but I couldn’t remember if they were the ones you mentioned in a previous comment section. I really like that bronze color and think it would be great for Spring with that little bit of shimmer it has
Now you know! The bronze one is really beautiful but I think the green is probably my favorite!
these look great especially of they are as good as the urban decay ones! great post
Thanks so much for reading! I certainly think they are just as good. I still love the Urban Decay and ultimately they do have a much broader color choice than the L’Oreal. But the textures are so, so similar!
Your welcome and I do hope they come out with more colours!
Me too! ❤️
I”m seriously going to have to get one of these! I’ve been eyeing them, but you’ve just sold me on it! 🙂
You need ‘em! 😉
I have three of them and I love them. They have the same lasting power as the Urban Decay eyeliners for sure!
Yesss! 😉
These are awesome! I repurchased the black pencil multiple times!
Aren’t they?? These are, like, the discovery of 2019 so far for me!
I usually hate pencil liners because they almost always tug but these ones sound really nice, especially with the long wear time!
So far (I’ve had ‘em for a good few weeks), no signs of tugging on me, which is a huge thumbs up. Now, who knows if they’ll be as smooth like a year from now, but I’m really enjoying them at the moment, especially as an alternative to the Urban Decay ones (which I still love dearly).
Hopefully they’ll still apply well over the next few months! I go through eyeliner so fast. Oh yes the UD ones would be expensive to buy all the time.
I use to wear eyeliner all the time. You make me want to try it again!
These are particularly nice! I talked a friend into buying the black one, and she really likes it too. If you have oily eyelids, you may want to set it with a powder to ensure longevity.